Skip to content

Artwork professor sues after firing over Prophet Muhammad pictures

Aram Wedatalla, a Hamline University senior and the president of Muslim Student Association (MSA), cries during a news conference at CAIR-MN office, Wednesday, Jan. 11, 2023, in Minneapolis.  A Hamline University lecturer showed a painting of the Prophet Muhammad and Wedatalla was one of the students in the class when the image was displayed.  (Kerem Yücel/Minnesota Public Radio via AP)

Aram Wedatalla, a Hamline College senior and the president of Muslim Pupil Affiliation (MSA), cries throughout a information convention at CAIR-MN workplace, Wednesday, Jan. 11, 2023, in Minneapolis. A Hamline College lecturer confirmed a portray of the Prophet Muhammad and Wedatalla was one of many college students within the class when the picture was displayed. (Kerem Yücel/Minnesota Public Radio through AP)


Attorneys for an adjunct artwork professor mentioned Tuesday she is suing the Minnesota college that dismissed her after a Muslim pupil objected to depictions of the Prophet Muhammad in a world artwork course, whereas the college admitted to a “misstep” and plans to carry public conversations about educational freedom.

In her lawsuit, Erika López Prater alleges that Hamline College — a small, non-public faculty in St. Paul — subjected her to spiritual discrimination and defamation, and broken her skilled and private repute.

“Amongst different issues, Hamline, via its administration, has referred to Dr. López Prater’s actions as ‘undeniably Islamophobic,”’ her attorneys mentioned in an announcement. “Feedback like these, which have now been printed in information tales across the globe, will comply with Dr. López Prater all through her profession, doubtlessly leading to her incapability to acquire a tenure observe place at any establishment of upper schooling.”

In Minnesota, a lawsuit might be began by serving a summons and a criticism to the occasion being sued. Attorneys for López Prater mentioned the lawsuit was served to Hamline College on Tuesday and can quickly be filed in court docket.

Hamline College President Fayneese Miller and Ellen Watters, the Board of Trustees chair, launched a joint assertion Tuesday saying latest “communications, articles and opinion items” have led the college to “evaluation and re-examine our actions.”

“Like all organizations, typically we missstep,” the assertion mentioned. “Within the curiosity of listening to from and supporting our Muslim college students, language was used that doesn’t mirror our sentiments on educational freedom. Based mostly on all that we have now realized, we have now decided that our utilization of the time period ‘Islamophobic’ was due to this fact flawed.”

The assertion didn’t tackle the lawsuit, however mentioned the college strongly helps educational freedom, which ought to co-exist with help for college kids. The college plans to carry two public conversations in coming months, one on educational freedom and pupil care and one other on educational freedom and faith.

Final October López Prater confirmed the 14th-century portray depicting the Prophet Muhammad in a lesson on Islamic artwork. For a lot of Muslims, visible depictions of the Prophet Muhammad violate their religion, which López Prater knew.

In accordance with the lawsuit, López Prater’s course syllabus included a word that college students would view pictures of non secular figures, together with the Prophet Muhammad. The syllabus additionally included a proposal to work with college students uncomfortable with viewing these pictures.

She additionally warned the category instantly earlier than exhibiting the depiction of the Prophet Muhammad. She mentioned in media interviews final week that her purpose was to show college students concerning the “wealthy range” of attitudes towards such imagery.

López Prater has mentioned she and the division chair have been discussing her educating a brand new course, however after the scholar’s criticism she was instructed “her providers have been not wanted.”

Hamline’s president beforehand mentioned the professor’s contract was not renewed following the autumn semester.

The lawsuit alleges that as a substitute of Hamline recognizing López Prater confirmed the pictures with a correct educational goal, the college selected to impose the scholar’s non secular view that nobody ought to ever see pictures of the prophet on all different college students and staff.

On Friday, the Council on American-Islamic Relations, a nationwide civil rights group for Muslims, disputed the idea that López Prater’s habits was Islamophobic. The group mentioned professors who analyze pictures of the Prophet Muhammad for tutorial functions usually are not the identical as “Islamophobes who present such pictures to trigger offense.”

At a information convention final week organized by supporters of López Prater’s firing, the scholar who filed the criticism mentioned she had by no means seen an outline of the Prophet Muhammad till the October class.

“It simply breaks my coronary heart that I’ve to face right here to inform people who one thing is Islamophobic and one thing truly hurts all of us, not solely me,” mentioned Aram Wedatalla, president of Hamline’s Muslim Pupil Affiliation.

The college mentioned on Tuesday it has realized a lot concerning the complexity of displaying pictures of the Prophet Muhammad and understands differing opinions on the problem exist throughout the Muslim neighborhood.

“Greater schooling is about studying and rising. We’ve definitely realized and proceed to develop as we generate new information to share with all of our Hamline neighborhood,” the assertion mentioned.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *